40% of Cigarettes in Guatemala Are Illegal: A Public Health Crisis

The illicit trade in this product is also a serious problem and affects other nations in Latin America, says Juan Carlos Buitrago in this interview, a retired Colombian general with more than 30 years of experience in national and international security, as well as studies in police and business administration inside and outside his country, in various intelligence agencies.


Formal companies that trade cigarettes in Guatemala are affected by large quantities of product entering as contraband from China, Korea, Paraguay and Cambodia, reported the Commission for the Defense of Formal Trade of the Chamber of Industry (CODECOF).


Four out of every ten cigarettes sold on the market enter the country illegally. In other Central American nations the situation is worse.


In Nicaragua, for example, it is estimated that eight out of ten cigarettes entered as contraband, while in Panama five out of every ten cigarettes consumed are illegal products, adds CODECOF.


During the first half of 2024, cigarettes worth more than Q30 million were seized at the Inter-institutional Checkpoints (PCI). In addition, in coordination with the Superintendency of Tax Administration (SAT) and the Public Prosecutor's Office (MP), 34.6 million cigarettes were destroyed.


Smuggling affects the economy,  health and security of Guatemala. Each year the SAT fails to collect some Q36 million due to illicit cigarette trade, according to Muriel Ramírez, coordinator of CODECOF at the Guatemalan Chamber of Industry.


Juan Carlos Buitrago: “Cigarette smuggling affects the economy, public health and security of the region”


What data is available on the increase in cigarette smuggling across Latin America?

In the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean, there is an annual upward trend in the circulation and consumption of illegal cigarettes. Colombia has experienced a 10% increase in cigarette smuggling over the last 6 years: illicit trade accounted for 25% in 2018 and reached 35% in 2023. Panama and Ecuador showed a 19% increase. Chile recorded the largest increase, going from 26.9% in 2018 to 49.5% in 2023 — an increase of 22.6%.


Which countries are the most affected?

Panama, where 92% of the cigarettes on the market are contraband, followed by Ecuador, where 84% of the tobacco trade is illicit, while in Brazil 54% of cigarettes are contraband, and in the case of Colombia 35% in 2023.


What negative effects is cigarette smuggling causing on formal trade and health?

There is a mistaken perception that smuggling has no victims or consequences. However, this idea ignores the harm to consumers' health from products that do not meet quality and safety standards. It also overlooks the negative impact on fair competition and on the State's tax revenue. This revenue is crucial for governments to fund essential public services in areas such as education, sports and health. At the Illicit Trade Research, Monitoring and Analysis Centre (CIMA), 473 operational events of illicit trade have been identified, mostly in Colombia, Ecuador and Panama, with an estimated value of US$158,186,622, which were highly likely to have been diverted to the illegal economy controlled by organized crime groups, and this is just a small sample of the reality of illicit cigarette trade. However, there is another consequence: cigarette smuggling affects not only the economy and public health, but also the security of the region. Cartels, which are no longer limited to drug production and sales, have diversified their operations into new markets, with cigarettes being one of their favorites. This business has become one of their main sources of financing, and they frequently fight for control of routes and markets, generating violence in the region.


Where are the smuggled cigarettes coming from?

66% of the illegal cigarettes in the region come from Paraguay. However, China, in recent years, has become an important source of illegal cigarettes. Authorities in countries such as Nicaragua, Panama and Colombia report large quantities of Chinese cigarettes (Golden Deer and Silver Elephant), which arrive at the Colón free zone or the ports of Cartagena or Santa Marta. Other origins include South Korea, the United Arab Emirates, Uruguay and India.


What are the authorities doing to counter cigarette smuggling?

Several countries have stepped up their efforts to combat smuggling by tightening border controls and joining international cooperation. One example is Colombia, where changes have been made to the customs statutes, applying the advance import declaration and modernizing the foreign trade system with international standards, improving competitiveness and transparency. Authorities have carried out operations in collaboration with international entities and the private sector. The authorities of Colombia and Ecuador have established 27 control actions that resulted in the seizure of 413,614 packs of cigarettes in the border region, emphasizing public-private collaboration to develop effective strategies.


How does the proposal for joint work between nations help combat cigarette smuggling and smuggling in general?

Cigarette smuggling is a phenomenon that knows no borders, so it is appropriate that its solution should not either, hence the importance of joint work between nations to confront this challenge. From this logic the Triangles Strategy was born, the strategic and operational public-private alliance to combat illicit trade in Latin America and the Caribbean, seeking through regional cooperation to reduce the incidence and negative effects of illicit trade in the region. One year after the creation of the Triangles Strategy, the customs authorities of Colombia, Ecuador and Panama recorded an increase in seizures of illicit cigarettes. In the specific case of Colombian Customs, seizures increased 150% from 2022 to 2023. As leader of the Triangles Strategy, I have witnessed that joint work between nations, achieving a shared vision, helps dismantle criminal structures and design more effective operations. The exchange of experiences and best practices has an impact on the prevention and control of illicit trade.


Are cigarettes the most smuggled product today?

Currently, cigarettes are one of the products most affected by illicit trade in Latin America and the Caribbean. Their small size and high value make them attractive to organized crime. However, they are not the only ones: alcoholic beverages, medicines, textiles and electronic products are also industries affected by this crime.


Content originally published in RPP Guatemala: https://rrppguatemala.com/2025/01/24/40-de-los-cigarrillos-en-guatemala-son-ilegales-una-crisis-de-salud-publica/ on January 24, 2025