Written by: Strategos BIP Analysis Team


Analysis of Illicit Trade in Mass-Consumption Products (Lighters, Toothbrushes and Razors) in Colombia

According to the DIAN, smuggling exceeded US$8.8 billion in 2022 and represented about 10% of the value of goods entering Colombia. Smuggling reduces the country's tax revenue, creates unfair competition and is a mechanism used in drug trafficking, to name some of its negative effects. The DIAN has consistently used the “mirror methodology” to estimate the size, impact and trends of this illicit phenomenon. Following this same methodology, Strategos BIP, with the support of industry, carried out an analysis of illicit trade for three products: lighters, toothbrushes and razors.


The distortion in the value of imports of just these three products was greater than US$20 million in 2023, representing 0.28% of the total distortion of all merchandise imports of the country in the same year (US$6,934 million). In addition, for these three products the combined distortion percentage is 65% of the value of imports; significantly higher than the 10% average across total imports according to the DIAN.


Excluding over-invoicing, since it has no direct negative fiscal effect, for 2023 the estimated overall distortion indicator stood at (40.07%), a considerably less alarming figure, as it would mean that for every COP $10,000, COP $4,000 of these three products are being affected by smuggling. In addition, just as happens at the country level, the most determinant modality was technical smuggling through under-invoicing.


Analysis of Illicit Trade in Mass-Consumption Products (Lighters, Toothbrushes and Razors) in Colombia – image 2

The amount the Colombian State failed to collect in customs duties and taxes was a total of COP $18.5 billion, broken down as follows: COP $8.1 billion in tariffs and COP $10.3 billion in VAT.


Analysis of Illicit Trade in Mass-Consumption Products (Lighters, Toothbrushes and Razors) in Colombia – image 3

In the breakdown of the analysis performed, the percentage of import distortion and the distortion value (USD) reached the following figures:

● Lighters: 69% - $12,217,966.

● Razors: 78% - $5,063,990.

● Toothbrushes: 42% - $3,070,706.


While it is true that with the issuance of Decree 659 of 2024 the National Government established measures to achieve greater and more effective control of merchandise smuggling, it is also true that this measure may be insufficient if it is not accompanied by other measures that give the customs administration additional tools for customs control, as well as information and proposals that may be useful for this purpose.

 

Given the dynamics of international trade distortion that has been described, the implementation of the following public policy and regulatory measures is put up for consideration, taking tariff splitting, minimum descriptions and reference prices as measures that can complement each other and may be of priority nature:


Analysis of Illicit Trade in Mass-Consumption Products (Lighters, Toothbrushes and Razors) in Colombia – image 4

See the full analysis here:

 

Strategos BIP is a consulting firm specialized in investigation, security and the protection of legal trade in Latin America and the Caribbean. It has coverage across the Americas, with a permanent presence in Miami, Bogotá, Mexico and Guatemala. It was founded in 2020 by Brigadier General (RA) Juan Carlos Buitrago Arias of the Colombian National Police, and was the first consultancy focused on preventing and combating illicit trade in the region. It has a team of professionals in diverse areas, including investigation, intelligence, data analysis, security risk management and strategic communication. For more information, you can contact us at: info@strategosbip.com.


Analysis of Illicit Trade in Mass-Consumption Products (Lighters, Toothbrushes and Razors) in Colombia – image 6